• If you are citizen of an European Union member nation, you may not use this service unless you are at least 16 years old.

  • Work with all your cloud files (Drive, Dropbox, and Slack and Gmail attachments) and documents (Google Docs, Sheets, and Notion) in one place. Try Dokkio (from the makers of PBworks) for free. Now available on the web, Mac, Windows, and as a Chrome extension!


Comments: Area 1C

This version was saved 11 years, 9 months ago View current version     Page history
Saved by Jennifer Nelson
on January 11, 2010 at 6:13:10 pm


1C:  misplaced comma in third example



Substitute “creator’s autograph” for “signature”?

Suggested rewrite for 2nd sentence: “For devised titles, a statement of responsibility may be included as part of the title proper.”

3rd sentence: “… record statements pertaining to responsibility for the production of the physical object (e.g., copyists, secretaries, or scribes) in the Notes area a note."

Comment on last example: “Comment: Printed” here refers to the style of writing (i.e., printed, as opposed to cursive)


1C. rule says to exclude copyiests, secretaries, or scribes, but shouldn't they be included if they're part of the formal statement of responsibility on the piece? This conflicts with 1C4.1, where it talks about two or more persons performing different functions. In case it helps, it's routine in Graphics to transcribe the name of the person who creates the physical object as well (e.g. the illustrator who makes the design *and* the woodcutter who makes this particular instance of it). 



“… in the form and order in which they appear.”




“If the name(s) of the person(s) or persons in the statement of responsibility are is abbreviated, unclear, or known to be a pseudonym, make an explanatory note.”




“Record this fact” doesn’t seem DCRM to me. Usually, you would say what to do with the statement of responsibility, then instruct to make a note. 1C1.4 could be rewritten: “Make a note that the statement …”


1st example: In the note text, substitute commas (?) for the double dashes




Add at end: “Make a note indicating the transposition” (cf. DCRM(B) 1E3) and add notes to examples.




F&p: 1st example: Delete space in “W.H.”; add space to “Jan. 1936”




“… transcribe all the names mentioned in the form and order in which they appear. [insert paragraph]

Optionally, if the responsible persons …”

Last example: put square brackets around “et al.”


1C5. Paragraph ends with the instruction “Indicate the omission by the mark of omission and supply “et al.” in square brackets.” but the third example does not include the square brackets.




F&p: Should “pucelle” be lowercase? Proper noun?




3rd par.: Insert comma after “phrases”

1st example : Delete space in “L.N.”; lower case “professor” and “phrenology”

2nd example: Insert space between mark of omission and semi-colon

4th example: Is date in the right place? Shouldn’t it precede statement of responsibility? Spell out “circa” (cf. 1D5)?

5th example: Need mark of omission after author’s name; in comment, delete hyphen in “title page”


1C10.2 -- Although parallel titles are mentioned here, there is no information in the current draft for how to record parallel titles (as in AACR2 4.1D or DCRM(B) 1C).




1st example: Lowercase “husband”; uppercase “Latten”? Spell out “circa” (cf. 1D5)? 

1C -- The following sentence is very confusing: “Do not supply a statement of responsibility for a manuscript lacking this element; instead, record creator information in the Note area and, optionally and for devised titles only, in the title area.”


1C14.3. Need an example here? 


1C14.3 -- Incorrect reference to 1F at the end of last sentence.

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.